TV recap: ‘Welcome to Flatch’ and that old Flatch magic

WELCOME TO FLATCH: L-R: Holmes and guest star Kyle Selig in the “That Old Flatch Magic” episode of WELCOME TO FLATCH airing Thursday, April 14 (9:31-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. © 2022 FOX Media LLC. Cr: Brownie Harris/FOX

Welcome back to "Welcome to Flatch" recaps! In this week’s episode, "That Old Flatch Magic," Kelly inspires Dylan to return to his passion for magic with a visit to Flatch’s new magic and vape shop, Smokus Pocus. Meanwhile, Shrub finally takes Beth on a date. Just starting the show? Here’s our recap of the premiere. Ready to binge? The first seven episodes are streaming on Hulu.

Good news "Welcome to Flatch" fans: "That Old Flatch Magic" just might be the best episode of the series yet. The fledging storylines the show has been establishing in its first few episodes really start to pay off this week. And all of the members of the show’s quirky small town ensemble get something meaningful to do.

Plus "That Old Flatch Magic" finds a really fun hook when a new magic shop (and vape store!) called Smokus Pocus opens in town. That seems to put a little something special in the air in an episode with a fun new guest character, three major romantic storylines and one disastrous retirement home magic show. 

So let’s break it all down, "Prestige"-style!

The pledge


WELCOME TO FLATCH: Sam Straley in the "That Old Flatch Magic" episode of WELCOME TO FLATCH airing Thursday, April 14 (9:31-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. © 2022 FOX Media LLC. Cr: Brownie Harris/FOX

After making the shocking discovery that "The Notebook" is not a so-bad-its-good Pixar film about a pad of paper, cousins Shrub (Sam Straley) and Kelly Mallet (Holmes) decide to check out Flatch’s new magic shop (and vape store!) Smokus Pocus. And maybe it was the night spent weeping over Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams, but romance is in the air: Shrub is looking for something to impress his long-time crush Beth (Erin Bowles) on their first date, and though Kelly initially writes off the whole shop as "lame," she changes her tune when she sees her grade school crush Dylan (Kyle Selig) rediscovering his childhood love of magic. 

WATCH FREE ON TUBI: "The Notebook"

As previously established, Dylan has a less-than-healthy relationship with his controlling wife Nadine (Taylor Ortega), who forced him to give up magic back in high school because she thought it was uncool. But this week, Nadine is out of town on a "Babes and Babies" glamping trip with her sorority sisters. So Kelly encourages Dylan to get back into magic, and even offers to be his assistant for a comeback performance at the local retirement home. 


WELCOME TO FLATCH: Guest star Murray Hill in the "That Old Flatch Magic" episode of WELCOME TO FLATCH airing Thursday, April 14 (9:31-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. © 2022 FOX Media LLC. Cr: Brownie Harris/FOX

Thankfully, Smokus Pocus owner Murray Hillman (guest star Murray Hill) is just the showbiz expert to get them started. (In fact, he feels like he stepped directly out of the 1940s.) Murray offers to help Dylan and Kelly jazz up their act by lending them his coveted Zig-Zag Lady trick in exchange for some free Smokus Pocus advertising. And while Murray is busy winning over local protestor June (Karen Huie) — who accuses him of being a practitioner of black magic — all the rehearsal time adds some fascinating new layers to Dylan and Kelly’s relationship.


Kyle Selig and Holmes in "Welcome to Flatch" (Screenshot: FOX)

"It’s been really fun reconnecting with Kelly," Dylan gushes. "She and I used to have fun all the time when we were kids." Fun is clearly something Dylan has been missing lately. (Nadine’s idea of a good time is cleaning out the attic with her bare hands.) But while it’s charming to watch Dylan and Kelly goof around together as they practice their act, "Welcome to Flatch" doesn’t lose sight of the fact that he’s a married man with a new baby. That makes this potential love triangle a lot more complicated than your average sitcom will-they-won’t-they.

RELATED: TV recap: ‘Welcome to Flatch’ welcomes a provocative art class

The turn


WELCOME TO FLATCH: Guest star Desmin Borges and Aya Cash in the "That Old Flatch Magic" episode of WELCOME TO FLATCH airing Thursday, April 14 (9:31-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. © 2022 FOX Media LLC. Cr: Brownie Harris/FOX

The Mallet cousins put their romantic plans into action on Friday night, when Dylan and Kelly perform their magic show at the retirement home while Shrub and Beth enjoy their first date at China Wok, Flatch’s upscale Chinese restaurant. And what’s especially enjoyable about "That Old Flatch Magic" is the way it manages to weave the rest of the show’s ensemble into those storylines too. For instance, Cheryl (Aya Cash) and her new beau, "Pockton Gazette" editor Jimmy (Desmin Borges), enjoy their own date night at China Wok just a few tables away.

Plus Shrub and Beth barely have a chance to glance at the menu (which thoroughly befuddles the steamed-chicken-loving Beth) before Shrub’s frenemy Mickey (Justin Linville) crashes their date with his grandma in tow. While Mickey claims he’s just trying to help Shrub out, it seems pretty clear his own affection for Beth is clouding his judgement. Soon enough, he’s launched into a hilariously bizarre game of one-upmanship involving elaborate animal napkin folding. 


Erin Bowles and Justin Linville in "Welcome to Flatch" (Screenshot: FOX)

Meanwhile, over at the retirement home, Big Mandy (Krystal Smith) opens for Dylan and Kelly with an original hymn she wrote earlier that afternoon. Though we see a quick look of panic from Father Joe (Seann William Scott) when he learns the often crass Mandy will be performing an original number, she nails it with an absolutely gorgeous vocal performance and some lovely lyrics — at least until she ends the song with a rhyme so inappropriate it has to be bleeped out. Classic Big Mandy.


WELCOME TO FLATCH: Krystal Smith in the "That Old Flatch Magic" episode of WELCOME TO FLATCH airing Thursday, April 14 (9:31-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. © 2022 FOX Media LLC. Cr: Brownie Harris/FOX

Still, that’s nothing compared to how wrong things go for Dylan and Kelly. While the beginning of their act unfolds smoothly enough, Kelly’s attempt to glam up her look with an old bridesmaids dress winds up backfiring on her. The frilly neon green gown gets stuck in the Zig-Zag Lady box, which not only ruins the trick but also eventually ruins the entire contraption as well, when Mandy winds up smashing it to pieces trying to get her out. 

"Now I know why I don’t wear dresses," Kelly grumbles after the fact. 


WELCOME TO FLATCH: L-R: Guest star Kyle Selig and Holmes in the "That Old Flatch Magic" episode of WELCOME TO FLATCH airing Thursday, April 14 (9:31-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. © 2022 FOX Media LLC. Cr: Brownie Harris/FOX

The prestige

The magic mishap puts the kibosh on Dylan’s act (and his friendship with Kelly), especially once Nadine returns and gets rid of his magician stuff. But things are looking more hopeful for this episode’s other two couples. Though the residents of Flatch aren’t too thrilled about Cheryl seeing someone from Pockton, she and Jimmy eventually share an odd but sweet first kiss. 

And it turns out Beth actually had a blast on her strange double date night too. She makes plans to have a more properly romantic date with Shrub the next time and even gives him a kiss on the cheek after he walks her home. 


WELCOME TO FLATCH: L-R: Guest star Erin Bowles and Sam Straley in the "That Old Flatch Magic" episode of WELCOME TO FLATCH airing Thursday, April 14 (9:31-10:00 PM ET/PT) on FOX. © 2022 FOX Media LLC. Cr: Brownie Harris/FOX

Indeed, the show’s central "you win some, you lose some" thesis is starting to take "Welcome to Flatch" to some interesting places. As Murray might say, "That’s showbiz!"

"Welcome to Flatch" airs Thursdays on FOX. The first seven episodes are also currently available to stream on Hulu. Recaps run weekly.

About the writer: Caroline Siede is a film and TV critic in Chicago, where the cold never bothers her anyway. A member of the Chicago Film Critics Association, she lovingly dissects the romantic comedy genre one film at a time in her ongoing column When Romance Met Comedy at The A.V. Club. She also co-hosts the movie podcast, Role Calling, and shares her pop culture opinions on Twitter (@carolinesiede).

This station is owned by the FOX Corporation.

More romance, magic and vapes — streaming free on Tubi

The Notebook (2004): Rachel McAdams and Ryan Gosling deliver some of the best chemistry ever captured on film in this classic tearjerker based on a Nicholas Sparks novel. "The Notebook" might not have been nominated for any Oscars, but it 

did win the MTV Movie Award for "Best Kiss." And that’s a piece of cinematic history in its own right. Rated PG-13. 123 minutes. Dir: Nick Cassavetes. Also featuring James Garner, Gena Rowlands, James Marsden, Sam Shepard, Joan Allen

The Illusionist (2006): Edward Norton stars as a 19th century magician in this gripping mystery that came out the same year as Christopher Nolan’s magician thriller "The Prestige." "The Illusionist" offers more of a focus on romance, however, as Norton’s Eisenheim The Illusionist attempts to help his childhood love Duchess Sophie Von Teschen (Jessica Biel) escape an arranged marriage with the villanous Crown Prince Leopold (Rufus Sewell). Rated PG-13. 109 minutes. Dir: Neil Burger. Also featuring Paul Giamatti, Aaron Taylor Johnson, Eleanor Tomlinson, Eddie Marsan.

The Freak Brothers (2021): Smoke 'em if you got 'em! Pete Davidson, Woody Harrelson and John Goodman lead the voice cast of this adult animated stoner comedy based on Gilbert Shelton’s cult classic comic, "The Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers." The series follows three 1960s hippie stoners who smoke a magical strain of weed, only to fall into a 50-year slumber and wake up in the 2020s. While time (and weed culture) may have changed, the Freak Brothers are just as mellow as ever. "The Freak Brothers" is a Tubi Original. Rated TV-MA. One season, 8 episodes. Also featuring the voices of Tiffany Haddish, La La Anthony, Adam Devine.

About Tubi: Tubi has more than 35,000 movies and television series from over 250 content partners, including every major studio, in addition to the largest offering of free live local and national news channels in streaming. The platform gives fans of entertainment, news and sports an easy way to discover new content that is available completely free.

Tubi is available on Android and iOS mobile devices, Amazon Echo Show, Google Nest Hub Max, Comcast Xfinity X1, Cox Contour, and on OTT devices such as Amazon Fire TV, Vizio TVs, Sony TVs, Samsung TVs, Roku, Apple TV, Chromecast, Android TV, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X | S, and soon on Hisense TVs globally. Consumers can also watch Tubi content on the web at

Tubi and this television station are both owned by the FOX Corporation.